There are so many myths about the Bible and Judaism, that I thought I would mention a few and clear the air. When I hear such statements as “I don’t believe certain individuals really existed; or, I don’t think that really happened (especially miracles),” I know that I am talking to someone who has not studied the truth.
EXAMPLES:
Adam and Eve. Was there
really a first couple or is this just an allegorical example of the beginning
of human beings? It’s interesting that
scientists have discovered that 99% of all human DNA
is common in all humans and is called mitochondrial DNA . This means that the differences that we have,
hair color, eye color, height, head shape, etc are all contained in only 1% of
our DNA structure. Paleontologists have concluded that all
humankind has descended from one woman.
Since this mitochondrial DNA
is past down through the mother and is found in every man as well, they believe
also that we all have descended from one man.
Paleontologists call this original couple, ready for this one, Adam and
Eve. Those scientists are so
clever. There are estimates that modern
behavioral humans have been around for about 10 to 50,000 years. Here again, scientists are getting close but
don’t have the correct number since it is definitely 5772 years since Adam and
Eve were created. We will talk more
about that when we compare Torah to science (coming soon to a blog near you).
What other proof do I have that the first couple was real
people? If they weren’t, then who is
buried in their graves? I happen to live
about a half hour’s drive from where they are buried in Hebron
in the Cave of Machpelah . Genesis 23 records the purchase by Abraham of
a plot of ground in Hebron
for a burial cave for his wife Sarah. In a deal that foreshadows many
such other Middle Eastern deals; Abraham paid an outrageous 400 shekels of
silver to Ephron the Hittite. Later, along with Sarah, Abraham,
Isaac, Rebecca, Jacob and Leah would be buried here. Jacob’s wife Rachel is buried in Bethlehem , which happens
to be about 15 minutes away. What
brought Abraham to this cave in the first place? One day when Abraham was grazing his sheep
and one went astray, he found the sheep at this cave and noticed an odor
emanating from the entrance. He entered
to discover that within the cave was the entrance to the Garden of Eden which
was the pleasant odor he was experiencing.
He then realized that this is the burial cave of Adam
and Eve. This is the building that was
erected over the cave that is today used by thousand of visitors, especially
for prayer.
There is much to be said about all this but the most important idea
is the not only were Adam and Eve real people but also the patriarchs and
matriarchs. A side note is that the
Garden of Eden also is real. Throughout Israel one can
see the burial spots of most of the people in the Torah and even the
Bible. The prophets, the Rabbis of the
Talmud, the kings, etc are accounted for and not just legendary names, and
definitely not mythical people.
I happen to live near many of the occurrences depicted in the
Bible. Not too far from me is the valley
where David fought Goliath.
This panoramic view of the Elah Valley
from the south is an approximate view of what the Philistine army saw as they
faced the Israelites in the battle (the highway in the middle was added
later). The Philistines were encamped on the south side of the valley and
King Saul's forces occupied the hill on the northern side. Yes, it is a real story and they were real
people.
West of this area is where Samson lived and fought. Yes, he also was real.
A controversy of the existence of the two Temples can be solved by many archeological
finds. They have found so much that they
know came from the time of the Temples . It is easier to send you to sites such as
this (there are more – just Google away to your hearts content).
The best evidence is the fact that the Moslem Wakf has been
destroying as much evidence as they can since the Arabs don’t want the truth
known. They are totally aware of what
was on the Temple
Mount ; but, it’s not good
for business or Arab propaganda if they can’t perpetuate their myth. The biggest lie comes from the fact that
Islam only dates back to the 7th century, about 600 years after the
2nd Temple
was destroyed. They certainly can’t lay
claim to the area if they didn’t even exist.
I have always been fascinated by the myth that
the Torah was coauthored by many and some of the mythinterpretation (there goes
my spell check again) of what is said in the Torah. As I had pointed out in Prayer Works
(continued) 10 Apr 12, that there are many names for Hashem. Two of the most important are L-rd and G-d
(of course that is the English translation).
L-rd is the name which has a connotation of mercy – G-d is the name of
judgment. The beginning of the Torah
only uses the name of judgment and later it switches to the name of mercy. The so-called experts therefore stated that
this was due to a change in writer. They
didn’t consider Adam and Eve were created on the sixth day and mercy was not
needed before that. In fact, since the
first five days of creation were Hashem creating and judging that it was good,
His name for judgment was appropriate.
It’s easy to make mistakes when you are a literary expert and only evaluating
literary style but not an expert in the text that you are evaluating. Then, there are those who misinterpret words
to satisfy their own agenda. The name of
Hashem connoting judgment has what appears to be a plural ending. Generally in Hebrew words are made plural by
adding an “im” (for a masculine word) or “ot” (for a feminine word) to the end
of the word. The actual translation of
the name used for judgment is “the G-d of many powers.” Powers being plural gives the name a plural
ending but it is definitely only talking one G-d. This, of course, has been used by gentile
clergy and missionaries for thousands of years who claim that this is proof of
the trinity concept. They say “you can see
it is right in the beginning of your Torah the idea of g-ds, plural.” The absolute proof of them making an intentional
mistake is that in Hebrew, as in many languages, the verb agrees with the
subject of the sentence. Since it says
G-d created the heaven and the earth and the verb created is in the first person
singular form, it absolutely cannot be translated as g-ds created. Those who say it is, are greatly sinning and
have completely mythed the boat.
There are no errors in the Torah. If someone finds an error, it is definitely
that person’s error, not Hashem’s. There
are so many misinterpretations especially if you have a translation in a
different language. People are not aware
that the King James Version of the Bible has an estimated 20 to 30,000
differences than the Hebrew Jewish Bible.
Most are strictly interpretive changes but many are intentional to
create prophecies that aren’t valid.
When text in Hebrew is translated into Greek and then into Latin and
finally into English, many errors creep in due to the incompatibility of
languages. But when your agenda is to
purposely change the text, we are back into the sinning category. Hashem’s word is sacrosanct and not to be
changed in any way. He who does will not
be happy on his or her judgment day.
I have many more myths but have decided to continue
tomorrow. If you have a myth that you
have heard and are curios about, send me a comment or an Email, today, and I
will try to include it in tomorrow’s post.
very nice readig
ReplyDeleteeventhough i read most of it before in one context or the other
i couldn't produce it so flawless and concise
excact and nice and good
as you can
but we are humble beings
never mind
keep it up !!
(didn't know the DNA story, or did i?)
I am curious about the following myths and notions:
ReplyDeleteNote: I do not intend to offend with some of following questions yet as of now I have been unable to find a proper satisfactory answer based on Halacha.
1 – The secular claim of a roughly 48.000 year gap between the lifetimes of Y-Chromosomal Adam and Mitochondrial Eve.
2 – The insular notion that some Jews have that a return to the ways of our forefathers entails adopting European / Western customs on dress / etc (believing that only their way / Minhag is correct and getting offended when people dispute their assertions), while denigrating other non-Euro / Western Jewish groups when the latter even a century ago lived how many imagine the Biblical forefathers to have lived (with Teimani Hebrew being very close to Ancient Hebrew with one or two arabic-influanced exceptions).
3 – Continuing on from 2, is the notion I heard from the same groups that the climate in Israel was more like Europe and that Vitamin D Deficiency and Rickets did not exist for women like it does now for muslim women, while white or light colored clothing / etc apparently do not keep you cooler in the heat.
4 – The source / text of a Gemarah in Avoda Zara (20 a and b) which tells the story of a great sage who had a chance visual encounter with a woman of great beauty and instead of responding in a manner typical of some groups actually made a Bracha - a blessing thanking God for creating a woman of such beauty.
1. The secular people claim many things but we know that they were created 5772 years ago.
Delete2. I always like to ask "what is Hashem's opinion." Go to tractate Taanis (I saw this years ago and don't remember the daf) to see discussion and what is said about the way we should dress.
3. I have no knowledge of this. Sorry.
4. From the Artscroll Siddur
Upon seeing exceptionally beautiful people, trees or fields:
Blessed are You, HASHEM, our G-d, King of the universe,
Who has such in His universe.