Friday, July 6, 2012

Seven Principles of Jewish Leadership

We are free. We are responsible. And together we can change the world.

I was recently asked to write the foreword to a publication being produced by the Adam Science Foundation to mark the 20th anniversary of its leadership program. Named after the late Adam Science, who died tragically in 1991 at the age of 27, the program has had great success in developing the next generation of lay and professional leadership within Anglo-Jewry. It has helped to produce leaders and leadership for a new age with its old-new challenges.

The phrase “Jewish leadership” is ambiguous. It means leadership by Jews, but it also means leadership in a Jewish way, according to Judaic principles and values.

The first is common, the second rare. Throughout my life it has been a privilege to witness both. So by way of saying thank you for the past and giving blessings for the future, I have set out below seven of the many axioms of leadership done in a Jewish way.

Principle 1: Leadership begins with taking responsibility.
Compare the opening of Genesis with the opening of Exodus. The opening chapters of Genesis are about failures of responsibility. Confronted by Hashem with their sin, Adam blames Eve, Eve blames the serpent. Cain says, “Am I my brother’s keeper?” Even Noah, “righteous, perfect in his generations,” has no effect on his contemporaries.

By contrast, at the beginning of Exodus Moses takes responsibility. When he sees an Egyptian beating an Israelite, he intervenes. When he sees two Israelites fighting, he intervenes. In Midian, when he sees shepherds abusing the daughters of Jethro, he intervenes.

Moses, an Israelite brought up as an Egyptian, could have avoided each of these confrontations, yet he did not. He is the supreme case of one who says: when I see wrong, if no one else is prepared to act, I will.
At the heart of Judaism are three beliefs about leadership: We are free. We are responsible. And together we can change the world.

Principle 2: No one can lead alone.
Seven times in Genesis 1, we hear the word “tov” (good). Only twice in the whole Torah does the phrase “lo tov” (not good) appear. The first is when Hashem says, “It is not good for man to be alone.” The second is when Jethro sees his son-in-law, Moses, leading alone and says, “What you are doing is not good.” We cannot live alone. We cannot lead alone. Leadership is teamsmanship.

One corollary of this is that there is no one leadership style in Judaism. During the wilderness years there were three leaders: Moses, Miriam and Aaron. Moses was close to Hashem. Aaron was close to the people. Miriam led the women and sustained her two brothers. The sages say it was in her merit that there was water to drink in the desert.

During the biblical era there were three different leadership roles: kings, priests and prophets. The king was a political leader. The priest was a religious leader. The prophet was a visionary, a man or woman of ideals and ideas. In Judaism, leadership is an emergent property of multiple roles and perspectives. No one person can lead the Jewish people

Principle 3: Leadership is about the future. It is vision-driven.
Before Moses can lead he has to experience a vision at the burning bush. There he is told his task: to lead the people from slavery to freedom. He has a destination: the land flowing with milk and honey. He is given a double challenge: to persuade the Egyptians to let the Israelites go and to persuade the Israelites to take the risk of going. The latter turns out to be more difficult than the former.

Along the way, Moses performs signs and wonders.

Yet his greatest leadership act occurs in the last month of his life. He gathers the people together on the bank of the Jordan and delivers the speeches that constitute the book of Deuteronomy. There he rises to the greatest heights of prophecy, his eyes turned to the furthest horizon of the future. He tells the people of the challenges they will face in the Promised Land. He gives them laws. He sets forth his vision of the good society.

He institutes principles, such as the septennial national assembly at which the Torah is to be recited, that will periodically recall Israel to its mission.

Before you can lead, you must have a vision of the future and be able to communicate it to others.

Principle 4: Leaders learn.
Leaders study more than others do. They read more than others do. The Torah says that a king must write his own Sefer Torah which “must always be with him, and he shall read from it all the days of his life” (Deut. 17:19). Joshua, Moses’s successor, is commanded: “Keep this Book of the Law always on your lips; meditate on it day and night” (Joshua 1:8)
Without constant study, leadership lacks direction and depth.

This is so even in secular leadership. William Gladstone had a library of more than 30,000 books. He read more than 20,000 of them. Gladstone and Benjamin Disraeli were both prolific writers. Winston Churchill wrote some 50 books and won the Nobel Prize for Literature.

Visit David Ben-Gurion’s house in Tel Aviv and you will see that it is essentially a library with 20,000 books. Study makes the difference between the statesman and the politician, between the transformative leader and the manager.

Principle 5: Leadership means believing in the people you lead.
The rabbis gave a remarkable interpretation of the passage in which Moses says about the Israelites, “They will not believe in me.” Hashem said to Moses: “They are believers the children of believers, but in the end you will not believe.” They also said that the sign Hashem gave Moses when his hand became leprous (Exodus 4:6) was a punishment for casting doubt on the Israelites. A leader must have faith in the people he or she leads.

There is a profound principle at stake here. Judaism prefers the leadership of influence to the leadership of power. Kings had power. Prophets had influence but no power at all. Power lifts the leader above the people.

Influence lifts the people above their former selves.

Influence respects people; power controls people.

Judaism, which has the highest view of human dignity of any major religion, is therefore deeply skeptical about power and deeply serious about influence. Hence one of Judaism’s greatest insights into leadership: The highest form of leadership is teaching. Power begets followers.

Teaching creates leaders.

Principle 6: Leadership involves a sense of timing and pace.
When Moses asks Hashem to choose his successor, he says: “May the Lord, the Hashem who gives breath to all living things, appoint someone over this community to go out before them and come in before them, who will lead them out and bring them in” (Numbers 27:16-17).

Why the apparent repetition? Moses is saying two things about leadership. A leader must lead from the front: he or she must “go out before them.” But a leader must not be so far out in front that, when he turns around, he finds no one following. He must “lead them out,” meaning, he must carry people with him. He must go at a pace that people can bear.

One of Moses’s deepest frustrations – we sense it throughout the biblical narrative – is the sheer time it takes for people to change. In the end, it would take a new generation and a new leader to lead the people across the Jordan and into the promised land. Hence the rabbis’ great saying: “It is not for you to complete the task but neither are you free to desist from it.”

Leadership involves a delicate balance between impatience and patience. Go too fast and people resist and rebel. Go too slow and they become complacent.

Transformation takes time, often more than a single generation.

Principle 7: Leadership is stressful and emotionally demanding.
Listen to Moses, the greatest leader the Jewish people ever had: “Did I conceive all these people? Did I give birth to them? Why do you tell me to carry them in my arms, as a nurse carries an infant, to the land you promised on oath to their ancestors?... I cannot carry all these people by myself; the burden is too heavy for me. If this is how you are going to treat me, please go ahead and kill me – if I have found favor in your eyes – and do not let me face my own ruin” (Numbers 11:11-15).

Similar sentiments can be found in the words of Elijah, Jeremiah and Jonah. All at some stage prayed to die rather than carry on. Transformative leaders see the need for people to change. But people resist change and expect the work to be done for them by their leader.

The responsible life is the best possible life, worth all the pain and frustration.

When the leader hands the challenge back, the people turn on him and blame him for their troubles. So Moses is to blame for the hardships of the desert. Elijah is to blame for disturbing the peace. Jeremiah is to blame for the Babylonians. No wonder the most transformative leaders feel, at times, burnout and despair.
Why then do they lead? Not because they believe in themselves. The greatest Jewish leaders doubted their ability to lead. Moses said, “Who am I?” “They will not believe in me.” “I am not a man of words.” Isaiah said, “I am a man of unclean lips.” Jeremiah said, “I cannot speak, for I am a child.” Jonah, faced with the challenge of leadership, ran away.

Leaders lead because there is work to do, there are people in need, there is injustice to be fought, there is wrong to be righted, there are problems to be solved and challenges ahead. Leaders hear this as a call to light a candle instead of cursing the darkness. They lead because they know that to stand idly by and expect others to do the work is the too-easy option. The responsible life is the best life there is, and is worth all the pain and frustration. To lead is to serve; The highest accolade Moses ever received was to be called “eved Hashem” – Hashem’s servant – and there is no higher honor.

Additional note:
This article was interesting to me because of something I heard many years ago from a Rabbi in the states.  In scriptures it tells about the lack of leadership that we will experience in the time before Moshiach.  Rather than leaders who are caring and want to help the people they lead, there will be leaders who are out for themselves in a very greedy and selfish way.  What more profound sign that Moshiach is just about here than the leaders of today.  I can’t think of one country that has a beneficent, caring individual who wants what is best for his or her subjects.  Hashem’s plan is obvious.  When Moshiach is introduced and leads by the seven principles stated above, we will truly know that Moshiach is a servant of Hashem and here to lead with goodness and righteousness.  That will certainly be a welcome change.
Have a great Shabbos  


  1. Sir.... I don't know if you are already a Rabbi or not, but if you aren't you certainly should look in this direction.

    Your blogs are so inspirational and uplifting... anymore that's all one can say about all the blogs... they are so inspirational and challenging.

    Thank you for all your blogs. You bring the information down to ones level (even if he is not up on your level)...and bring us UP!!! (If that's said correctly)... it's meant as a .. Thank you!!

    May we all merit seeing the arrival of Moshiach.

  2. May we all merit to be called an "eved Hashem."

  3. BS"D

    As the Nekuda of Moshiach, which is the Nekuda of Pnimius Atik (Ein Sof sh"b Radla), is in the Yehida of Every Jewish man and woman.

    Say Yechi, Charley!

    So in the time of redemption, the Yechida of a precious few is awaken, and that person perceives Moshiach in him or her self, and hence in the world.

    In redemption "beita" more people gain this consciousness, and by uniting in a web of networks, and revealing the wellsprings of kabbalah and chassidus, bring this consciousness to the world

    At some critical point, as the network reaches a level (as hinted by the Rebbe that "Moshiach is received by 1, 2, 3 people...) - "Achishena" kicks in, with the beginning of revelation of the miraculous dimension within the physical dimensions of Time and Space.

    With the coming of Moshiach ben Dovid, teichef umiyad MMSh.

    Yechi Adoneinu Moreinu VeRabeinu Melech HaMoshiach LeOlam VaEd

    Ad Mosay?!